Susato Kildare Large Bore Low F tunable Review
(Review written May 2004)
- Preface
- I actually bought this whistle in June 2003, in hopes of using it with my band in Houston--many of the songs were sung in F. And then I had to move to Dallas for work. Such is life!
- At a Glance
- Whistle Reviewed
- Susato Kildare Large Bore Low F tunable
- Models Available
- Various keys and sizes, tunable and non-tunable
- How Acquired
- Purchased new
- Construction
- Plastic
- Price at Time of Review (in US Dollars unless otherwise noted)
- $79.90
- Available From
-
Kelischek Workshop and pretty much anywhere tinwhistles are sold.
- Appearance
- Nothing says 'Susato' like a Susato. You just can't mistake them. They have a characteristic look, and if you've met other whistle players, chances are you've seen one or three. Susatos are pretty much "king of the factory whistle", so they're everywhere, just like Yamaha dominates the plastic recorder world.
-
Here's an overall view of the whistle. It's got the small beak, straight lines, cylindrical tuning slide, and that kind of knurled end like any susato you'll come across. This is a pretty fat whistle, but not as fat as a low D. I've layed it on a gaming map to take pictures as an experiment. The dark whistles don't photograph as well with a white background..too much contrast. As a side-effect, you can estimate the size of the whistle, as each square is 1 inch in size.
Here's a shot of the head, giving a view of the labium ramp and head design. It's pretty standard for Susatos.
You barely see it, but it has a curved windway to help wick away moisture. As near as I can tell, the entire whistle, including head and fipple, are all one uniform type of plastic. The beak (the part you put in your mouth) is very short, and people who are used to Generations, Sweetones, Oaks and the like, will find that it feels quite "stubby". I like this better, though, as it keeps the whistle out from between my teeth, so I don't chew on it.
- Playing Characteristics
- This whistle is characteristic of the Susato line: Pure in tone. It can be a little shriek-y on the 2nd octave A and B, but not like Susato Ds can! It's got a nice rich tone.
-
Sound clips of the whistle:
Flower of ScotandVolume: This whistle plays medium lound. I would expect that in a medium-size session, you'd blend in pretty nicely. Louder than that and you'd be lost completely.
Responsiveness: This whistle is very responsive. I'm able to sneak in ornaments and clips and blips without any issues. The bottom two notes are a little slow to respond sometimes, giving a tendency to squeak if you're playing fast.
Tuning: The instrument, when blown with the proper breath control, is in tune across the range. As mentioned, you do have to push C-natural a little bit. I'm only able to get about a 5-cent variance with breath control, making this whistle very consistent and appropriate for beginners. But it does mean the whistle will lack some of that "soul"...you can't color notes with breath control. The whistle is in-tune with the tuning slide out nearly a quarter inch, giving you a lot of control over tuning to folks who are out of true.
D# (An F whistle's equivalent to a C-natural): OXXOOO produces an in tune D# (an F whistle's equivalent to a C-Natural) if you push it a little with your breath. If you drop any other fingers (OXXXOO or OXXXXO) the whistle goes extremely flat.
Hole size and placement: This whistle has holes are on the smallish-size for a low whistle. You'll have to use "low whistle fingering" to play this whistle. Thus, I'd expect most people to have to use piper's grip, or use their pinkie (as I do) to hit the lowest hole.
Air volume requirements: Low-medium. I can get about 80% through the A part of a reel before I have to take a breath.
Air pressure requirements: Low. This whistle's just very easy to play. Doesn't take much breath, and you don't have to really push it in the 2nd octave, unlike other Susatos.
Clogging: I can't recall any Susato ever clogging up on me. But then again, I've never played one for hours and hours, so I just can't speak to this much. My impression is that they'd be pretty clog resistant.
Misc Notes: You can get susato low whistles with an angled-head option for $20.00 more. This makes it hold more like a sax and less like a whistle, giving you a break on your wrists if you have carpal tunnel or something. This is a neat option.
- Summary
- This is a pretty good whistle. Like all Susatos, it's consistent and predictable. I wish I'd had more chances to play it with the band before I had to move.